A fintech’s first SOC 2 engagement starts with customer assurance requirements, payment and data flows, and a defensible system boundary. Reuse relevant evidence from existing security or payment obligations where it applies, while documenting differences. Assign owners for remediation, operating evidence, and auditor coordination before committing to fieldwork dates.
Key Takeaways
•For the next operating decision, compare compliance for technology companies with managed compliance services.
•Define the system boundary before assuming existing payment controls cover the whole engagement.
For fintech startups — whether building payment processing, lending platforms, banking-as-a-service infrastructure, investment tools, or insurance technology — the first SOC 2 audit is frequently the compliance milestone that unlocks bank partnerships, enterprise customer contracts, and institutional investor confidence.
Unlike general SaaS companies where SOC 2 is one of several possible compliance frameworks, fintech startups face a market where SOC 2 Type II is functionally mandatory: bank partners require it before sharing customer financial data, enterprise clients require it in vendor security assessments, and institutional investors evaluate it during due diligence.
The challenge for fintech startups pursuing their first SOC 2 is that financial data sensitivity, regulatory intersections with PCI DSS and state money transmitter requirements, and the specific expectations of bank and financial institution buyers create additional complexity beyond a standard SaaS SOC 2 engagement.
This guide provides a fintech-specific step-by-step checklist for going from zero to a completed first SOC 2 Type II report, covering fintech-specific preparation steps, bank partner requirements, PCI DSS overlap considerations, and a phased timeline from initial planning through report delivery. If this is your team's first encounter with SOC 2 at all, start with our plain-English Startup's Guide to Buying SOC 2.
How should a fintech plan its pre-audit assessment?
Week 1-2: Scoping and Strategy
How should a fintech plan its pre-audit assessment? — comparison
Step
Action
Fintech-Specific Considerations
1
Define your SOC 2 system boundary
Include all systems that process, store, or transmit financial data — payment processing APIs, banking integrations, KYC/AML systems, transaction databases, and customer-facing applications
2
Select Trust Service Criteria
Fintech startups should include Security (required), Confidentiality (strongly recommended for financial data), and Processing Integrity (strongly recommended for financial calculations); Availability if platform uptime is contractually committed
3
Identify bank partner and regulatory requirements
Survey your bank partners' specific SOC 2 expectations; some require specific criteria or observation period coverage
4
Determine PCI DSS overlap
If you process, store, or transmit cardholder data, assess PCI DSS requirements alongside SOC 2; plan for coordinated compliance
5
Set your target timeline
Work backward from your bank partner deadline or enterprise deal timeline to set your observation period and audit dates
Week 3-4: Readiness Assessment
How should a fintech plan its pre-audit assessment? — comparison
Step
Action
Expected Findings for First-Time Fintech
6
Conduct a readiness assessment
Use your GRC platform's automated assessment or engage an advisory firm for a fintech-specific evaluation
7
Inventory all financial data flows
Map how financial data moves through your system — from customer input through processing, storage, and transmission to bank partners
8
Assess current security posture
Evaluate existing controls against SOC 2 criteria; expect gaps in formal documentation, access reviews, and vendor management
Budget for remediation: costs vary based on the number and complexity of gaps identified during the readiness assessment
Common Readiness Gaps for Fintech Startups
How should a fintech plan its pre-audit assessment? — comparison
Gap
Why It Is Common
Remediation Priority
No formal access review process
Startup teams grow quickly; access expands without formal review
Critical — bank partners specifically evaluate access management
Incomplete MFA enforcement
Service accounts or legacy accounts without MFA
Critical — any account without MFA is a finding
No formal change management
Rapid development without documented approval and testing
Critical — change management is a core SOC 2 control area
Missing incident response plan
No formal plan beyond "fix it when it breaks"
High — incident response is required; financial incident scenarios needed
No vendor management program
Multiple fintech-specific vendors (banking APIs, KYC providers) without formal assessment
High — fintech has a dense vendor ecosystem that must be managed
No formal risk assessment
No documented risk identification and treatment process
High — required by CC3 criteria
Encryption gaps
Data at rest not fully encrypted; some API connections not using TLS 1.2+
Critical — financial data encryption is non-negotiable
No security training program
No documented security awareness training for employees
Medium — required but can be implemented quickly
What should the control implementation stage accomplish?
Week 5-6: Foundational Controls
What should the control implementation stage accomplish? — comparison
Step
Action
Fintech-Specific Details
11
Enforce MFA for all users
Enable MFA on all accounts including service accounts with interactive access; use hardware tokens for production infrastructure access
12
Implement role-based access control
Design RBAC model with fintech-specific roles: transaction viewer, payment processor, bank integration manager, compliance officer
13
Configure encryption
Enable encryption at rest for all financial data stores; verify TLS 1.2+ for all API connections; implement field-level encryption for sensitive fields (SSN, account numbers, routing numbers)
14
Set up logging and monitoring
Deploy centralized logging; enable cloud provider audit trails; configure alerting for security events and financial transaction anomalies
15
Configure a GRC platform
Set up Vanta, Drata, Secureframe, or Sprinto; connect integrations; begin automated evidence collection
Week 7-8: Process Controls
What should the control implementation stage accomplish? — comparison
Step
Action
Fintech-Specific Details
16
Formalize change management
Implement branch protection, PR approval requirements, and deployment workflows in your CI/CD pipeline
17
Create incident response plan
Include financial-specific incident scenarios: unauthorized transactions, payment processing failures, bank API outages, customer financial data exposure
18
Conduct initial risk assessment
Document risks specific to financial data processing: fraud risk, regulatory risk, bank partner risk, financial data breach risk
Engage a penetration testing firm with fintech experience; include API testing for financial endpoints
27
Run vulnerability scan
Scan all in-scope infrastructure; remediate critical and high findings; document remediation timeline for remaining findings
28
Verify all controls are operational
Review GRC platform compliance dashboard; confirm all controls show passing status
29
Test incident response procedures
Conduct a tabletop exercise using a financial-specific scenario (payment fraud, data breach involving financial records)
30
Verify evidence collection completeness
Confirm automated and manual evidence is being collected for all controls; address any gaps
PCI DSS Overlap Considerations
When PCI DSS Applies
PCI DSS Overlap Considerations — comparison
Scenario
PCI DSS Applicability
Coordination with SOC 2
Your platform processes cardholder data directly
PCI DSS required — you are a service provider under PCI DSS
Significant overlap with SOC 2; pursue both frameworks leveraging shared controls
You use a payment processor (Stripe, Adyen) that handles cardholder data
PCI DSS may not apply to you directly; SAQ may be sufficient
Focus on SOC 2; document your payment processor as a subservice organization
You store cardholder data (card numbers, CVVs)
PCI DSS required — storage of CHD brings full PCI DSS scope
Full PCI DSS compliance needed alongside SOC 2
You transmit cardholder data to a processor
PCI DSS applies — transmission is in scope
SAQ or full PCI DSS depending on volume; document transmission controls in SOC 2
SOC 2 and PCI DSS Control Overlap
Map existing payment-security evidence to the particular SOC 2 system and criteria. Access reviews, change records, and monitoring records may be useful, but the systems, dates, and objectives must match. Confirm suitability with the auditor; a PCI assessment does not substitute for a SOC 2 opinion.
Which bank partner requirements should you confirm?
What Bank Partners Evaluate
Which bank partner requirements should you confirm? — comparison
Requirement
How to Address
Evidence to Prepare
SOC 2 Type II report
Complete your SOC 2 engagement; provide the report with NDA
Auditor-issued SOC 2 Type II report
Encryption of financial data
Field-level encryption for sensitive fields; TLS for all bank API connections
Auditor conducts fieldwork; evidence reviewed; control owners interviewed
Report delivery
Depends on scope and readiness
Final SOC 2 Type II report delivered
Total timeline
Depends on scope and readiness
First SOC 2 Type II report in hand
New to SOC 2? Download our free Startup's Guide to Buying SOC 2 — a plain-English, 10-minute read for first-time founders and CTOs.
AICPA & CIMA’s SOC overview describes CPA assurance services. It defines the assurance context; it does not establish vendor rankings, market prices, or a particular company’s readiness.
Frequently Asked Questions
How does PCI DSS overlap with SOC 2 for fintech?
Substantially. Encryption, access control, logging, vulnerability management, and vendor oversight satisfy requirements in both, so evidence collected once can serve each — provided you scope and document it to cover both frameworks from the start.
What do bank partners require beyond SOC 2?
Bank partners layer their own diligence on top: a completed security questionnaire, evidence of BSA/AML controls where relevant, business continuity documentation, and often a right to audit. A SOC 2 report shortens that review but does not replace it.
Tyler Carbone
Managing Director and Cofounder
Tyler Carbone is a Managing Director and Cofounder of Agency and one of the industry's leading voices on governance, risk, and compliance. He holds degrees from Harvard and a JD/MBA from the University of Virginia, and previously worked in cybersecurity at Deloitte. Tyler has helped hundreds of companies operate SOC 2, ISO 27001, HIPAA, and GDPR programs.
At Agency, we work with dozens of developer tools companies navigating SOC 2 — and the challenges they face are fundamentally different from a typical SaaS company.
·Tyler Carbone··10 min read
Stay ahead of compliance
Expert insights on cybersecurity compliance delivered to your inbox.